Pages

16 April 2021

No Talking in Shul!

 4 Iyyar 5781 / 19th day of the omer, which equals two weeks and five days of the omer count




 

 

 

 

 

 

by Rabbi Ephraim Sprecher  first published here

 

“My Shabbatot you shall observe, and My Sanctuary you shall revere.” (Vayikra 19:30). Rashi comments that giving the proper respect to the sanctuary (Beit Hamikdash) is expressed by not entering with one's walking stick, or while wearing shoes or a money belt or with dust on one's feet. Today we have no Beit Hamikdash, but the Gemara in Megillah 29 teaches that our shuls are מקדשי מעט which means mini sanctuaries and must be treated with great respect and reverence.
 
Tractate Derech Eretz Raba chapter 3, one of the 14 so called “minor tractates,” records an incident at the end of the life of R. Eleazar ben Azariah when he was seriously ill, his students came to him and asked him “How can we be worthy of life in the World to Come?” He answered them “Go out and be careful with the honor due to your friends, and when you are standing in prayer, know before Whom you are standing. This will earn you life in the World to Come.”
 
Chavos Yair wonders why R. Eleazar ben Azariah prefaces his advice with the words “Go out”. It seems out of place and irrelevant to the advice he offers.
 
He explains that R. Eleazar ben Azariah’s comment for addressing the great difficulty some people have avoiding talking during davening. This occurs mainly on Shabbat when friends see each other and have time to catch up on news of family, community or business. This is especially true now that many of us are back in shul, after a year, and some of us feel that we have to catch up with our friends, so we must be conscious of this.
 
Unfortunately this talking often takes place during davening or Kriat HaTorah, and leads to a desecration of Hashem’s sanctuary. At times a person feels that it is impolite not to respond to a question or comment from one's shul friend and feels compelled to talk, even if it is in the middle of davening in shul.
 
In this light, we can understand the message of R. Eleazar ben Azariah. If you want to be careful in the honor due your friends, then GO OUT of Shul and talk there. When you are davening in shul, be aware before Whom you are praying. This will earn you life in the World to Come!
 
If only people would take to heart the words of the Chavos Yair and thereby bring about a marked improvement in the decorum in our shuls, they would then merit the great benefits that come from sincere prayer.
 
***
 
(...and maybe Mashiah will feel welcome in our batei knessiot, be"H he should come any moment now? Shabbat shalom umevorach! - HDG)


No comments:

Post a Comment

I appreciate your comments and read them all. You are invited to visit again and, of course, leave comments. These are the rules:

1. This is a change brought about by my first foul, spam-worthy comment on the part of an anonymous commenter: I WILL NOT POST ANY MORE COMPLETELY ANONYMOUS COMMENTS. You MUST have at least a nickname at the end of your post, period. If you don't have enough courage to name yourself in some form or fashion, don't bother to comment here.

2. If you do not agree with content posted on this blog, please use polite ways of responding; make it easy for me to resolve conflict. Foul language, nastiness and attempts to convert me and my readers to other religions will be deleted. My blog; my call.

3. I, the blogger, reserve the prerogative to moderate comments, or not, without notice, for any reason.